Skin in the Game

There is advice from people who have carried a payroll, and advice from people who have not. It is not the same advice.

The difference is not intelligence, and it is not even knowledge, in the textbook sense. Plenty of people who have never operated anything can describe operating with real fluency; theory is clean, and clean things are easy to teach. Operating is the other thing. It is the payroll run in a bad month, when the maths works only if a specific invoice lands by Thursday. It is the board meeting after a miss, where the explanation must be honest and survivable at the same time. It is the hire that had to be unmade, slowly, properly, at a cost to everyone including you. It is the quarter where the plan and the cash disagreed, and one of them had to give, and you were the one who chose which. An adviser who has lived those carries a different quality of judgement, and the difference is audible within ten minutes of conversation, usually in what they do not promise.

Because that is the signature of carried weight: the promises shrink and the questions sharpen. People who have operated know how many ways a sound plan can lose, so they hedge where hedging is honest and commit only where they have earned the right to. People who have only advised have never paid for a confident sentence, so confident sentences cost them nothing, and they spend them freely.

My own answer to this check is on the record, and it is the sixth of the seven for a reason. Every chair: CEO, CFO, COO, CTO, CRO, CMO, CHRO, and non-executive board seats. A loss-making business turned profitable in three months, which is a sentence that reads cleanly and was lived one hard decision at a time, most of them unpleasant, several of them mine to deliver in person. And one more form of skin, the most literal there is: I invest my own money in startups and scaleups. Nothing sharpens judgement like your own capital at risk inside someone else's plan, because it converts every opinion you hold into something with a price.

So here is the check, for when you next buy help, and it takes one question with a follow-up. Ask what they have operated, not what they have advised; the distinction will be resisted precisely to the degree it matters. Then ask about the worst month. Not the case study, the worst month: what happened, what it cost, what they did. People who have carried the weight answer that question differently. They answer it slower. There is a pause while they choose which true thing to tell you, and the pause is the credential, because people without a worst month answer instantly, smoothly, and in the second person.

The same standard, pointed at your own business, is simply honesty about which chairs are genuinely carried and which are titles. The Entrepreneur Gap scan maps all eight in about ten minutes, free, built for businesses past £15k a month, and I have sat in every one of the chairs it asks about, which is exactly why it asks.

Continue reading: What Does Leaving Look Like →

Or check your business first: Take the free 10-minute Entrepreneur Gap scan →